What I learned from imagining a ground-floor apartment
When I retired early from teaching at 49, I knew I’d have to make unconventional financial decisions. One of the biggest was moving from New Jersey to Delaware in 2024. I purchased a townhouse in a neighborhood where I feel safe and comfortable, and I’ve enjoyed making it my home.
My annual pension is $36,000 gross, without a cost-of-living adjustment. I can earn some side income now to build a nest egg, but I can’t assume I’ll always be able to do so. What's working for me now might not work twenty years from now. There are no guarantees.
In a previous post, Planning for My Financial Future Without Giving In to Fear, I shared a list of potential future housing options. Today's post discusses my exploration of the fourth option, converting my ground floor into an efficiency apartment for myself and renting the upper two floors as a strategy to possibly help protect my retirement. At first, I was excited about this plan. Now I’m having second thoughts.
How tiny home and renovation TV programs have influenced me
I’ve enjoyed videos about going tiny for years—stealth van life, tiny lux, and DIY tiny home building. They make living in a 200-square-foot place seem glamorous and fun. The show Income Property has particularly inspired me in this ground-floor conversion idea. Watching homeowners transform basements into rental apartments makes it seem achievable in my own life.
I even used an online software program called Homestyler.com along with ChatGPT to create three-dimensional renderings of my vision. I'm pleased with the results!
But beautiful renderings and engaging TV programs alone don’t tell the whole financial story. They also don’t fully address the practical challenges of day-to-day small-space living.
Tiny-home shows do feature clever storage, like drawers under the stairs and storage beneath beds or benches. But they don’t always make clear whether people keep belongings somewhere else or even whether they live in those homes full time. And renovation programs don’t fully explore how the financial picture might look for people in different circumstances.
The storage problem I overlooked
During a practice tour in preparation for recording a related YouTube video, I walked around explaining where I’d put the kitchenette, bathroom, and furniture—and suddenly wondered where all my belongings would go.
I have clothing, furniture, household supplies, and possessions across three floors. They would never fit downstairs. I’d have to give up most of what I own, and I hadn’t even planned for adequate clothing storage!
I’ve considered building a large cabinet beside the television and keeping off-season clothes in the garage. Those options add cost, and I’d still have to downsize dramatically. Am I truly ready for that?
The complications behind the beautiful rendering
The apartment would need a kitchenette, powder room, shower, dressing area, and stacked washer and dryer, with another laundry arrangement for the upstairs renter. I cook most of my meals at home and would need to adapt to a smaller cooking area and portable appliances like an Instant Pot, hot plate, air fryer, and toaster oven rather than the full-sized oven I'm accustomed to using.
I'd need to hire professionals to evaluate plumbing, electrical service, ventilation, permits, zoning, egress, and insurance. Also, my HOA surely has strict rules concerning leasing and boarders. My drawing is a concept, not an approved plan.
I haven’t established whether a separate apartment would be permitted. Depending on what’s allowed, this might be more like sharing my single-family home with a roommate, possibly a family member or someone I know well. I’d still need to check the zoning and HOA rules to find out whether that arrangement would be allowed.
What about the backyard and garage?
I'd still keep access to those, while the tenant would have use of the deck and street parking. I love gardening, sitting in my rocking chairs, enjoying the firepit with my family, and working on my laptop outside when weather permits. My attached garage adds to my level of security when entering and exiting. Keeping the backyard and attached garage is a major reason I’ve considered this plan.
I’ve also imagined expanding my living space even more by adding a small permanent covered, screened-in porch immediately outside the sliding door leading to the backyard. But that would mean more money, maintenance, and approvals.
Why the financial picture changed
My mortgage payment is approximately $1,100 monthly, including taxes and insurance. I’ve estimated that my main level and third floor might rent for around $1,600.
The renovations I’m imagining could cost up to $70,000, possibly more. That’s a preliminary estimate, and the more I look at the plan, the more potential expenses I discover.
Initially, I imagined rent covering the mortgage, leaving about $500 toward other expenses, while I redirected the money currently allocated to my mortgage toward aggressive monthly renovation loan payments.
But then I realized something. I’d still owe the original mortgage and the renovation loan, even if the rental space sat vacant. I’d also be responsible for repairs, maintenance, insurance, and other rental costs. The $500 gap between projected rent and mortgage is not automatic or guaranteed profit.
Watching Income Property differently
Rewatching a few episodes of Income Property, I paid closer attention to the homeowners’ financial situations. Someone who can comfortably finance a renovation and repay the renovation loan quickly may have an excellent opportunity. I can't assume I’d be able to comfortably pay off a $70,000 renovation loan in five or six years.
I’m already working to pay down my mortgage and student loan. Taking on another substantial loan would add to the debt I’m trying to reduce, at a time when I’m hoping to create more financial breathing room.
And even if I were in a better financial situation and owned my house outright, would I really want to sacrifice most of my living space for a potential few hundred dollars extra per month?
I also have to ask myself whether I want the responsibilities of being a landlord at this stage of retirement. Repairs, another person’s needs, and uncertainty about whether they’ll stay would all become part of my life. Do I really want more responsibility right now?
Simpler alternatives and what I learned
Maybe I could someday share my existing bathroom and common areas of the house with a trusted friend or family member without taking on major renovation projects and without being forced to live in an efficiency apartment.
I don’t have to decide now. I’m grateful to be exploring these possibilities ahead of time. I still think the apartment idea is fun, but it’s not my first choice.
Would you downsize within your own home to generate rental income, or would you choose another approach? I’d love to hear your thoughts.
For more conversation on this and other early retiree topics, be sure to browse the playlists on my YouTube channel and visit my podcast on Spotify.
Comments
Post a Comment